Chiller energy-efficiency metrics may seem numerous, but in procurement decisions there are essentially only two categories that really need to be clarified: full-load steady-state efficiency and integrated part-load efficiency. COP, kW/TR, and EER belong to the former; IPLV belongs to the latter. Understanding their conversion relationships and applicable scenarios is more important than remembering any single “impressive number.”
1. Four Metrics, Two Logics
COP (Coefficient of Performance) is the most basic expression of efficiency: cooling capacity ÷ input power, dimensionless. A chiller with a COP of 6.0 means that for every 1 kW of electrical energy consumed, it produces 6 kW of cooling effect.
EER (Energy Efficiency Ratio) is essentially the same as COP, only expressed in different units. EER is expressed in Btu/W·h, and the conversion relationship is COP = EER / 3.412. Both are steady-state metrics under a single operating condition, usually measured under AHRI standard full-load conditions.
kW/TR (kW per Ton of Refrigeration) is the most commonly used expression in the US-customary chiller industry, directly putting “how many kW of electricity are consumed per ton of refrigeration” on the table. Its particularity is that the lower the value, the higher the efficiency, which is the opposite direction from COP/EER. The conversion relationship is:
kW/TR=12EER=12COP×3.412kW/TR=EER12=COP×3.41212
Conversely, COP = 12 / (kW/TR) / 3.412, and EER = 12 / (kW/TR).
IPLV (Integrated Part Load Value) is completely different in nature. It is not the efficiency at a single load point, but the result of weighting the efficiencies at four load points—100%, 75%, 50%, and 25%—according to operating-time weights. Under the AHRI standard, the common weights are 1% × A + 42% × B + 45% × C + 12% × D (A/B/C/D correspond to 100%/75%/50%/25% load, respectively). China’s GB 50189 system also adopts a similar weighting logic. The weight distribution itself is telling: nearly 90% of the weighting falls on the 50% and 75% load points, because chillers rarely run at full load for extended periods in reality.
A quick conversion reference:
(Calculated according to COP = EER / 3.412 and kW/TR = 12 / EER.)
2. Key Difference: Full-Load “Peak” vs. Annual “Actual”
COP, EER, and kW/TR answer the question: “How efficient is this machine at rated full load?” IPLV answers: “How much energy does it save on an integrated basis over most of its operating hours in a year?”
A centrifugal chiller with a full-load COP as high as 6.0 may not necessarily have better annual actual energy consumption than a unit with a full-load COP of 5.7 but still maintains high efficiency at 50% load, if its efficiency deteriorates sharply at low load. Conversely, if a project’s cooling load is stable at 85%–95% year-round, then IPLV’s weighting logic is disconnected from the actual operating conditions, and full-load COP (or kW/TR) is the more honest metric.
Industry data also confirms this divide. Taking mainstream machine types as examples: scroll chillers have a full-load COP of about 3.5–4.5 and an IPLV of about 4.5–6.0; screw chillers have a COP of about 4.0–5.5 and an IPLV of about 5.0–7.0; centrifugal chillers have a COP of about 5.5–7.0 and an IPLV of about 6.0–8.0. IPLV is systematically higher than COP precisely because condensing temperature under part-load conditions is usually lower, compressor pressure ratio decreases, and efficiency naturally improves. But this is not a “free lunch”—IPLV test conditions assume that cooling water temperature decreases with load. If the actual project’s water temperature control strategy does not match, the attractive nameplate IPLV may not be realized at all in operation.
FAQ :
FAQ 1: What are the differences among COP, EER, and kW/TR?
All three express the ratio of cooling capacity to input power in different forms: COP is a dimensionless ratio, EER is expressed in Btu/(h·W), and kW/TR indicates the input power per ton of refrigeration. The conversion relationships are COP = EER ÷ 3.412, and kW/TR = 12 ÷ EER = 3.516 ÷ COP. Higher COP and EER are better, while lower kW/TR is better; they cannot be directly compared in reverse.
FAQ 2: Why can selection not be based solely on full-load COP?
Nameplate COP, EER, and kW/TR are mostly based on AHRI 550/590 full-load standard conditions and cannot represent annual operating energy consumption. In typical load-time proportions, the shares of 100%, 75%, 50%, and 25% load are approximately 2.3%, 41.5%, 46.1%, and 10.1%, respectively, so the weighting of full-load operation is extremely low. For projects with load fluctuations, IPLV should be the primary anchor; only for scenarios operating at ≥90% full load year-round should full-load COP/kW/TR be used as the main basis.
FAQ 3: How should IPLV and NPLV be distinguished and used?
IPLV weights the efficiency at four load points according to 0.01A + 0.42B + 0.45C + 0.12D, and is suitable for standard part-load evaluation in typical cooling tower applications. If the water temperature, cooling method, or load profile deviates from standard conditions, NPLV should be used. At the same time, the power consumption of chilled/cooling water pumps and cooling tower fans should be included in the comprehensive energy efficiency evaluation of the plant room, avoiding comparison based only on unit nameplate COP.